By a Newsnet reporter
Media claims of an increase in anti-English racist attacks in Scotland have been described as “irresponsible and wrong” by the Scottish government.
The criticism follows publication of new figures last week which showed an increase in racist attacks in Scotland under the category “white British”.  The figures were reported by sections of the Scottish media as evidence that anti-English racism was on the increase.

However analysis of the figures has revealed that attacks against ‘white English’ actually fell in the last year in all police force areas which were able to provide a breakdown of the statistics.  The revelation has led to the Scottish government angrily denouncing the media coverage.

The statistics, which cover six of Scotland's eight police force areas, have emerged after the Scottish Government undertook further detailed analysis of the racist incident statistics which were released last week – and which led to some misleading and incorrect media interpretations of the data.

This further analysis shows that, for the six forces for which a breakdown is available, the number of racist incidents recorded by the police against people categorised white English victims fell by 17 per cent in 2011-12.

Meanwhile, racism against Scottish white victims increased by a quarter during the same period.

The analysis excludes Grampian and Strathclyde, as due to differences in recording systems these forces were unable to provide data giving a more detailed breakdown.

Cabinet Secretary for Justice Kenny MacAskill said:

"All racism is abhorrent whoever the victims are and it will not be tolerated anywhere in Scotland.  No community or group should be subject to discrimination and abuse because of their ethnicity, nationality or beliefs.

"This further new analysis shows that, where these more detailed statistics are available, racist attacks against white English people in Scotland are going down, and have decreased by 17 percent last year.  That decrease is to be welcomed, but there will be no let up in our efforts to drive down the number of racist incidents across the board.

"I encourage anyone subjected to a racist attack to report it to the police in the confidence that their complaint will be taken extremely seriously.  We are working tirelessly to tackle all forms of racism and discrimination.  Tough enforcement through record numbers of police officers on our streets, together with community engagement and education, can and will have an impact.  Together we can make a difference and ensure that modern Scotland is a tolerant and welcoming society for everyone."

The initial report of a ten per cent increase in overall racist attacks included an increase in the ‘white British’ category of 23 per cent.

The new statistics led to headlines in several newspapers suggesting the rise was evidence of anti-English sentiment in Scotland.  The headline in the Daily Record read: ‘MSPs demand action is taken after figures reveal anti-English racism is on the rise in Scotland’ whilst the Herald claimed there was a ‘Fear anti-English racism on rise’.

The media reports were seized on by Unionist politicians with Scottish Lib Dem leader Willie Rennie saying: “We cannot allow anti-English rhetoric to creep into society and the SNP Government must do all it can to combat this.

“While racism against some ethnic groups is falling, it is still far too prevalent in Scottish society.

“This includes racist abuse directed towards the English, which cannot be tolerated.”

The claims were also reported by BBC Scotland with the issue featuring on the Call Kaye Radio Phone in with host Kaye Adams claiming that “anti-English sentiment” was “up fifty per cent apparently over the last seven years” and linking the rise to politics.

The programme featured several callers making allegations of anti-English abuse with claims that the SNP were the cause.  Others claimed that supporters of Scottish independence “used” anti-English sentiment as an excuse.

The North East of Scotland was compared with Bavaria 1932, in a clear reference to the rise of Nazism, with the SNP again being blamed for anti-English "bullying".

A spokesperson for Justice Secretary Kenny MacAskill added:

“It was irresponsible and wrong of certain media outlets to portray a rise in racist incidents against white people as an increase in anti-English discrimination when the original statistics release did not support that claim – and as this further analysis shows such attacks have actually gone down.

“Any racist incident is unacceptable, against any individual or group, and will not be tolerated. Politicians and the media have a serious duty of care to report and portray these figures in an accurate and responsible way.”


[Newsnet Scotland is currently on a festive break.  There will be no scheduled daily news updates in the main news area - however from time to time, if a member of the team is available, they may draft an article on a story they feel is particularly important.]


# clootie 2012-12-16 23:25
Here we go again!
# RTP 2012-12-16 23:39
Newsnet Scotland is currently on a festive break. There will be no scheduled daily news updates in the main news area - however from time to time, if a member of the team is available, they may draft an article on a story they feel is particularly important.]

A very Merry Xmas and a Happy New Year to all the hard work you have done in giving us the true facts and not some of the garbage we get from BBC and MSM.
Thank you all.
# ThereWasACoo 2012-12-16 23:48
Back at ye!

Hae a guid Christmas and an even better Hogmanay!

# fynesider 2012-12-17 00:21
You guy 'n' gals deserve a break.... Have a good one all.
# Will C 2012-12-17 00:23
Enjoy your break folks, it is well deserved. Thanks for all the work you do in the struggle for our national self determination.
# nchanter 2012-12-17 00:29
Great job many thanks.
The best for the festive season to you all.
# kenneth_clark336 2012-12-17 00:54
This site has made a great difference to my life. I have noted on other forums that anyone quoting Newsnetscotland is immediately a target for vociferous attack, ridicule, and contempt by NO supporters. You are obviously doing something right! A whole thread I was involved with in Cornwall was removed by the moderator after a complaint, when I mentioned your name, with a link to the McCrone report. The guy who instigated the discussion told me the moderator claimed it had broken the rules. The whole thread! I guess telling a few truths comes under that heading. Enjoy your Christmas break. You deserve it.
# Mark 2012-12-17 00:57
A very Merry Xmas and a prosperous New Year to you all.
# Don 2012-12-17 01:12
Have yourselves nice one, you all deserve it, hope to see you all next year
# cjmasta 2012-12-17 01:19
Clootie, those four words say it all really! Newsnet, thankyou, merry Christmas and may your new year bring you the best of all things good and just. Time to make a Christmas donation I think. Merry Christmas to all those whose comments I regularly enjoy. Spare a thought for us Chefs who are working 80 hour weeks this month to provide the xmas parties to to all who still enjoy such luxuries.
# .Scot 2012-12-17 01:26
A Merry festive time to all at Newsnet & you WILL be missed. Haste ye back.
# graememcallan 2012-12-17 05:54
Hae yersels a Sparkly Xmas and a Fluffy New Year;-)))
# Balefire 2012-12-17 05:57
Merry Christmas Newsnet to you and yours.Come back fighting in the new year.
# Macart 2012-12-17 07:00
A merry Christmas and a guid new years to all at Newsnet. Keep the staff party civil mind. :)

As for the article, are we really that surprised that the Westminster parties would play the race card? They've levelled accusations of xenophobia and nazi party leanings since day one. Luckily in this instance they leapt before they looked and have been left with an eggy face.

There is no avenue, however low, they consider out of bounds. If it's negative, if it portrays either the independence movement or indeed Scotland in a bad light, they'll use it. There's only one way to end it. Vote yes.
# mountaincadre 2012-12-17 07:08
Aye aw the best over the festive period.
# McHaggis 2012-12-17 07:25
The Herald started this...

I recall trying to add a comment on their 'feature' stating they had taken a pure leap of faith in assuming racism against whites was anti-englishness but no surprise really, my comment was never printed.
# Angus 2012-12-17 07:33
All the the best to the NNS team, and many thanks for the efforts over the past year.

This latest effort seems like another attempt at fearmongering, probably aimed at people who have moved from England.
A simmilar article in the Scotsman looks as though it had backfired on them after it was shown that some of the unionist commentators had previously shown ill feelings towards Polish people and the Gaelic language. The article was pulled fairly quickly.
# hiorta 2012-12-17 08:02
Enjoy the break, People of Newsnet Scotland, yer daein' a grand job, although getting Unionists to value and speak truth instead of their lying propaganda may be beyond even your undoubted ability.
Ah well, we'll no' miss them.
# Diabloandco 2012-12-17 08:18
May I add my thanks to the team and good wishes for a merry Christmas and an excellent ,prosperous and diligent New Year!
# Jo Bloggs 2012-12-17 08:26
Racism is an odd term to use for presumed attacks by white Scots on white English, or are we supposed to believe black people in Scotland are suddenly attacking white english people? I'm bemused.
# Jim Johnston 2012-12-17 08:34
It should anger everyone that yet again the poison has been put in by the BBC and MSM, (even although a "regional" like the Herald is hardly Main Stream).

Hatred is being targeted and spread in and against Scotland by the BBC and MSM, of that there is no doubt. Real laws are long overdue to control their vile propaganda.
# farrochie 2012-12-17 08:49
Did the newspapers learn nothing from the Leveson inquiry? Accuracy and truth still seems to be concepts that don't interest the journalists. They are living in a past where they think they can feed bs to the public, but the numbers prepared to buy this keech is dwindling by the month. Confined to their offices, tied to the Press Association newswires, they haven't realised we can check the facts on the web. Journalists have lost their credibility.
# Breeks 2012-12-17 08:56
Thank you NNS. Enjoy your break, and recharge the batteries for next year.

As for the report? What else should we expect from Unionist rag sheets when the sound of a barrel being scraped is so difficult to put into words?
# mariaskid 2012-12-17 09:34
Have a restful break and return refreshed for the fray.. Thanks for this site which keeps me from despair at our dreadful media
# bringiton 2012-12-17 10:08
Interesting that the "media" regard Scots and English to be separate races.
# Taysider 2012-12-17 11:23
I understand that the Commission for Racial Equality (CRE) in Scotland has ruled that English and Scottish are for the purposes of the law different races so any anti-English nastiness can be dealt with ounder racial equality laws and quantified. I understand too that the CRE south of the border does not admit that that Scots and English are different races so anti-Scottish sentiment in England cannot be dealt with under racial equality laws and quantified.
# bringiton 2012-12-17 12:49
Maybe that's why most of the media are based in England,so that they can publish anti Scottish bile with impunity.
# James01 2012-12-17 10:13
According to the Unionist’s logic, or should that be lies, this website should be full of anti-English comments, yet it isn’t, you’d be loathe to find a single comment of such a nature. Yet if you venture onto the Daily Mail or Guardian’s website you’ll see their comment section filled with truly awful anti-Scottish rhetoric whenever they cover an independence related story. Funny how the Scottish media doesn’t highlight that. Thank you NNS for being a bastion of sanity throughout the year.
# rapid 2012-12-17 10:15
One of the most positive things I've heard from the YES campaign was the idea of "Scottish Identity" not being uniquely tied to an individuals origin or roots.

Certainly makes sense because 3 people I know who are fervently YES and identity themselves as Scottish have roots or origin from Finland, Pakistan and England.

I love this about our culture. It is so welcoming to all.
# soutron 2012-12-17 10:45
Absolutely @rapid, I think that's the key aspect of the Scottish form of nationalism...inclusion for anyone who wants to be a part of it (and even those who don't!). Scottish is a state of mind. That needs to remain a big part of the campaign to ensure that nobody feels marginalised or alienated.

And yes, some of the anti-Scots rhetoric in MSM comment sections is horrendous. I'm living in England at the moment for work and you'd be suprised by how many sensible, perfectly nice people buy into the idea that they are somehow subsidising Scotland and paying for our public services. It's not their fault, it's an inevitable biproduct of the MSM's bitter together barrage.
# soutron 2012-12-17 11:04
Oh and Merry Christmas Newsnet, I don't know what I'll do without you! Enjoy your well deserved rest. Looking forward to 2013. Saor Alba!
# Chateaulait 57 2012-12-17 11:28
Have a very Merry Xmas and a Happy New Year to all at NNS, you guy's have earned it.

Back on topic, my wife is English and moved here (Glasgow & North Ayrshire)twenty five years ago and has no experience of anti English racism, my brother on the other hand has lived in London for over thirty years and is finding anti Scottish remarks to him on the rise.
# flyingscotsman 2012-12-17 11:36
Excellent article, when I first saw this I knew they were up to no good. The story went from anti-english to anti-british to white-on-white, happily changing it whenever it suited and to make it appear the same. The combinations of what races could have been involved in the white-on-white racism statistics number in the hundreds. Despicable.

The link to the Herald story is linking to the Daily Record story btw
# .Scot 2012-12-17 11:50
So, the 1st ever Scot's Government is overseeing a reduction in racism, knife & gun crime, bigot attacks on the English & they have halted the falling population rates by massively increasing the number of people permanently living in Scotland? Here's how the British Broadcaster reported a 5% increase in Scottish population "England and Wales population up- 3%":

Contrast that with the vile manner that the Scottish media dealt with the great news of a 5% increase- "POPULATION TIME BOMB":

Racism? perhaps. Bigotry? Most definitely.
# bipod 2012-12-17 13:20
Have a look at the comments in this BBC article

The section is completely full of vile/ignorant comments. Most are about the so called "Subsidy". It is incredible that these same people have the gall to accuse independence supporters of racism.
# Blanco 2012-12-17 12:03
A colleague quoted this very news report in the pub, banging on about SNP Anglophobes... I replied that 'White British' covers more than just English and quoted back an academic study from 10 years ago (turned into a book, 'Being English in Scotland' by Murray Watson) where the author found that although there was a perception of expecting racism (thanks to media sensationalism) , hardly any of the English people he interviewed had experienced it (as opposed to, say, Pakistanis, but that's another issue)... my colleague then made some disparaging comment about Nichola Sturgeon's personal appearance, laughed to himself, and turned to someone else and changed the subject of conversation. Comment continued below…
# Caadfael 2012-12-17 12:04
Many thanks to all at and involved in Newsnetscotland , I wish all of you a Merry Christmas and a very happy, healthy and wealthy New Year! Lang may yer lum reek on ither buddy's coal!
Here's a wee bit of fun to help you pass the time!
# UpSpake 2012-12-17 12:10
I hate no-one. No-one is my enemy despite extreme political views. All they can ever be are political adversaries and we conduct our affairs by rational and calm debate. All views and any view is valid.
To hate is destructive and self defeating. It is possible to be extremely hostile to a creation and the British State is just that. That the British State just happens to reside within the most populous country of the Union and represents in many of its outlets, all that is wrong with the Establishment.
If I hate anything it is the damage and the utter subservience that has been wraught on the Scots people by a country who by its represenatitves finds its smaller neighbour utterly distasteful at every level and worthy of only disdain.
# proudscot 2012-12-17 12:29
Have a good Xmas and New Year break, NNS staff and all who contribute to the site.

On the subject of the Scottish media's inaccurate and deliberately misleading skewing of the "anti-ENglish" racist attacks stats, is anyone really surprised? No doubt the 3 Unionist Stooges will be quoting and using these inaccurate stats as an excuse to attack Alex Salmond and the SNP at the next FMQs. Shameful if they do, but then I don't think any of the No campaigners are capable of feeling shame.
# Blanco 2012-12-17 13:25
[Admin - You have used a term to describe opponents of independence that is frowned upon by this site. As a result your post has been removed.]
# From The Suburbs 2012-12-17 14:50
In the interests of fairness I am sure we will see front page banner headlines to-morrow on this story.

A senior legal expert has challenged the opinion of the European Commission president over the status of an independent Scotland in the EU.

Professor Sir David Edward, a former European Court judge, believes that Scotland and the rest of the UK would be in a comparable position.

There would be no need for a new accession treaty, he argued.

Instead, negotiations prior to independence would result in amended EU treaties.

Writing on the Scottish Constitutional Futures website, Sir David examined both the view of those such as Mr Barroso, who has said a newly independent state would have to apply to join the EU, and that of nationalists who have argued that Scotland would simply continue as a member of the EU after independence.
# Ready to Start 2012-12-17 15:10
The BBC has this story on its web site.
Here is the link to source

Still no coverage of Icelandic Presidents remarks or further coverage of businessman Mark Shaw's remarks about independence in Sunday Times.

Good news for the YES side is a NO go area for our anti Scottish independence press corps.
# RTP 2012-12-17 14:53
"Wind Wise Radio"

Its not just here in UK that we have to put up with anti SNP and our Government,have a look at the above site.
No matter what your take on wind-farms are we don't need the likes of Trump and his millions dictating what our Government do and his mocking of AS.The P&J and S/Post ran two adverts from Trump I suppose these papers are in need of the money and according to the Forbes family they were always ready to cosy up to Trump.
I have two English daughter in-laws so far from hating the English the are more than welcome in my house,its the Westminster establishment we don't like.
# robert de brus 2012-12-17 16:21
Thank you, thank you, thank you, to all and sundry at Newsnet Scotland for all the hard work and effort put in. May I wish you all a very Merry Christmas and Happy New Year. Long may you continue producing balanced and fair reports. To the other website contributors thanks for opening my eyes it has indeed been an education. Saor Alba and vote YES 2014.
# Albalha 2012-12-17 16:26
I hope the Scottish Government will be putting in a formal complaint re the Call Kaye programme ....... seems it was neither fair, balanced or anywhere near accurate.
# Katy Scott 2012-12-17 16:36
Thank you for all your hard work. You do a wonderful job in bringing balance to the news and many people are grateful. You will be needed more than ever next year, so have a good rest and a happy festive season.
# mealer 2012-12-17 16:38
Happy holidays to all at NNS.Your efforts really are making a difference.I'll be making a donation shortly.
# Edulis 2012-12-17 17:16

I have just been reading again Jim Hunter's 'The making of the Crofting Community'. There is no group of people so vile as those Scots who are on the make and regard Scotland as too parochial for their aspirations viz. all those clan chiefs who first of all simply assumed ownership of clan lands and then fully adopted another country's mores, including the full 'public school' (sic) ethos. For clan chiefs the modern equivalent must surely be the Westminster apparachiks.
# Soloman 2012-12-17 17:40
Well done to everone at Newsnet Scotland for another year of excellent reporting.
Merry Xmas and Happy New Year to one and all!
# ScotsCanuck 2012-12-17 17:49
To all the Lads & Lassies @ NNS a Merry Xmas and a guid New Year.

You are an oasis of truth in a desert of lies.

Haste ye back
# bleach 2012-12-17 18:17
Merry Christmas to all and well done to everyone at Newsnet Scotland for the excellent work that they always do !
# Nautilus 2012-12-17 18:32
I heard that so-called statistician claiming that there had been a 1,700 increase in 'racist' attacks against English people in Scotland.

There are statisticians and statisticians. A few are honest and draw conclusions from the data they collect. Most have an axe to grind or a product to promote and make the figures fit their theory. The guy on 'Call Kaye' was one of the latter.

No one asked him to give chapter and verse as to what he defined as a 'racist anti-English attack' or what the figures were last year to justify his assertion that there had been a rise. If they were indeed English, they would probably have got a bop on the nose in their own country just as easily just for being obnoxious. The so-called statistician had been told, probably by some southern rag to make up some damning figures.

Merry Christmas yo' all, and more power to your elbow in the New Year.
# JRTomlin 2012-12-17 19:12
Happy Christmas to all!
# Davy 2012-12-17 19:43
I would like to express my thanks to all the staff of Newsnet Scotland and to all of the writers of articles, comments and postings. It has been an honour to read, reply and engage with all of your works over the past year, and has'nt it been fun.

Due to you all and this site, I will look forward to 2013 with gusto and hope.

A Merry Christmas and a Happy New Year.

NNS Gu Brath.
# call me dave 2012-12-17 20:01
Johann Lamont raises questions over free tuition policy

Scottish Labour leader Johann Lamont has warned that publicly-funded higher education was "not viable" without a "serious" reduction in standards.
I noticed that there was very brief mention of this on BBC Scotland tv but the Lamont speech (or even a few sentences) was not broadcast.

The web site page has not really got any policy details but lots of references to what she thinks is wrong.
The side bar is a load of nonsense about her personal life as a teacher.
Even the Blether WB page which has a playback interview with her which is dated March.

Was there nothing of importance to report or no BBC Scotland staff to attend the event.
Maybe the content and quality of the speech was not up to BBC standards.
# Marian 2012-12-17 20:04
Gone are the days when you could listen or watch BBC news items and read news articles in quality newspapers and be fairly confident that you were getting a reasonable facsimile of the truth without it being massively embellished with political opinion or bias.

If you wanted opinion you could read the Editor's opinion piece to get his/her slant or better still make up your own mind.

Nowadays we are subjected to a torrent of spin or as I prefer to call it, propaganda, from all airts in our establishment controlled media.

Thankfully the web is replacing the dead wood that the establishment media has become.

I will be happy when the last tree is felled and the last TV licence is ever issued for the embarrassing caricature that our MSM and BBC news has become.

Long live Newsnet Scotland and all the other honest websites that tell the truth about the undoubted benefits to Scots of going independent.

Lang may yer lum reek!
# Andy Anderson 2012-12-17 20:23
This gross misrepresentati on by the media and BBC is utterly intolerable. We just can't allow this to continue.
Distorting the fact again, quite blatantly in order to mislead for political objectives this is appalling. If this had been happening in Eastern Europe by a state funded broadcaster the BBC would be declaring that this was a gross interference with democratic principles and would be insisting that it was interference in the ballot which would render the result invalid. We must insist that we will not allow this to happen to the Scottish people.
# Sunshine on Crieff 2012-12-17 22:04
I am a Scot, yet I am also English: the product of a Glaswegian father and a Cumbrian mother. I am endowed with a Manchester/south Lancashire accent, which marks me out as English to those who do not know me.

Yet I encounter almost no hostility based upon my perceived identity. I have certainly not come across any anti-English sentiments from anyone in the Yes campaign or the SNP. On the contrary, any hostility has come from unionists who, when they discover that I am part-English, have often stated that this issue has nothing to do with me (when they discover my enthusiasm for self-determination). I have even been confronted by the question of "why do I hate my fellow-countrymen" by one unionist, just because I am sympathetic towards independence.
# pictic-1 2012-12-17 22:15
People like myself who live and work abroad are so thankful that the internet exists, without it we would be utterly up the creek and living in a vacuum. Buying newspapers at the next local airport or whatever.

NNS / Wings o Scot. / Scoop it / Radio Free Scotland are a breath of fresh air and sanity.

Merry xmas to one and all, may you have a very good, prosperous new year.

"Each new day is a day nearer to freedom"
# ramstam 2012-12-17 22:55
I wisnae happy at aw tae hear Tam Cowan & co repeating the Daily Record story on "Anti-English Racism" on Off the Ball on Saturday. Tho Nicola Sturgeon is trying to ensure equal spending in the referendum we will struggle to get fair coverage from the Record and SOS.
Onywey cheer up an hae a Blythe Yuletide an a Guid New Year 2013.
# Will C 2012-12-17 23:47
@ Sunshine on Crieff -Well said and glad to hear that your 'Corrie' (forgive me if I got the geography wrong)accent has caused you little problem in Scotland. I would be furious if it had!
Independence has nothing to do with where you were born, who your mum and dad are/were, or what accent you happen to have. Independence is about people who want to live in Scotland, have a vision of what an independent Scotland could achieve and what legacy they could leave to their children.
# Sunshine on Crieff 2012-12-18 19:26
Quoting Will C:
@ Sunshine on Crieff -Well said and glad to hear that your 'Corrie' (forgive me if I got the geography wrong)accent has caused you little problem in Scotland. I would be furious if it had!

'Corrie' is more or less correct, although the Glaswegian/Cumbrian influence did have an affect on our accents.

And your other sentiments reflect my experiences of pro-independence people. "A Scot is someone who calls Scotland home" - I think Alex Salmond said that, but similar things have emerged from thw Yes movement.

As I said, my father was a Scot, and our ancestors gave us a set of surnames that suggest we've been in Scotland for the duration. Yet I also qualify as a 'New Scot' through the other part of my heritage, a label I wear with pride.

The No side? They tell me that my family and friends in England and Wales will be 'foreigners', a ridiculous idea. It is they who push the idea of narrow nationalism.
# Hamish100 2012-12-17 23:48
BBC Radio Scotland had Grahame Spiers talking re BBC sports personality of the year and refers to the anti-english views from Scotland--not challenged by ex rugby chancer--- Surely being pro-scottish is not in itself anti-english or anti-french etc just you want the best for your countrymen and women. How sad to see those Scots people so blinkered by THEIR little englander/ Britishness that is so anti-scots and Scotland
# Iaincraig 2012-12-17 23:53
I am more worried about the anti Scottish racism that is present daily in the British Press and Media and a racism that is getting increasingly nasty in its frequency and content. The BBC is particularly guilty of this.
# Will C 2012-12-18 00:28
@ Hamish 100 - I suspect we all know who you mean by the term "ex rugby chancer". I am getting sorely cheesed off with people who accuse people like us who do nothing more than promote our own country as being racist or anti-English.
I am old enough to remember the "I'm Backing Britain" campaign. Today, in 2102 and beyond, I'm backing Scotland and make no apology for it!
# Diabloandco 2012-12-18 07:37
# ButeHouse 2012-12-18 02:24
We look forward to your return. Like thousands of other YES people NewsNetScotland is now my first port of call for news anywhere.

Then the BBC website for the unionist 'interpretation' of the news.


Stay Positive VOTE YES
# Alathia 2012-12-18 08:21
2013 will be the year Scotland starts to wake up and realise that we're not too poor, stupid or wee.

Have a happy festive NNS.

Look forward to a few little gems over the hols.
I'm sure you won't resemble the 'tumbleweed' activity of Labourhame....
# rgweir 2012-12-18 12:16
My thanks to all at NS for giving us fair and balanced reporting.
I hope you have a well deserved break,I for one will miss my morning visit so please hurry back.
# Iaincraig 2012-12-18 14:18
Well today's interpretation of the census figures is that we are too old, senile and decrepit to be Independent. We have to be looked after by a younger, fitter and superior British Master Race.

The census figures are now being spun to run the residents of Scotland down again.

It begs the question who are the real racists? Or more acurately; Who are the real bigots?
# Milligan 2012-12-18 15:22
Yes, this story had me shouting at BBC radio Scotland once again, At no time did the report mention England or English but that didn't stop BBC radio Scotland reporting it like fact. As the seconds counted down i waited for the inevitable connection between this report and the SNP/Scottish Independence, Kaye Adams didn't let me down. . BBC radio Scotland are so predictable now it makes me laugh. .
# ianbeag 2012-12-18 17:26
Your contribution to balancing the argument for Scotland's independence has been outstanding - the growth in your readership is testimony to that. How rewarding for Newsnet Scotland to see your credibility and support escalating as the readership of most of the hostile print media plummets.
When the history of the YES campaign is written, the arguments won and independence delivered Newsnet will be applauded as a central pillar of the campaign and the struggle. Congratulations and thanks is also due to the loyal and committed squad of regular and well informed posters who spice up the articles on a daily basis.
Enjoy a well earned break.
# Clydebuilt 2012-12-18 17:50
Scotland on Sunday Linked Alisdair Gray with the BNP, job done some Journos might think.
But not our intrepid Graham Spiers, calls himself a sports journalist.
Re. Monday's John Beattie’s lunch time show on Radio Scotland, one of the topic’s
was BBC’s Sports Personality of The Year. Spiersey managed to suggest that if you were
a supporter of the SNP you wouldn’t have enjoyed “SPOTY” the reason being that someone who is a supporter of the SNP doesn’t like English people.
His postulating went unchallenged.

Tell yer Pals
# clootie 2012-12-18 19:00

Moore says we cannae use their bank - THEIR BANK mind yae. We canne join the EU. We cannae hae universal benefits.

It'll soon be 2013 I think? can wae still dae that withoot askin'

Poor stupid wee Scotland - we dinae ken when tae gie up!

Don't get me started on Trump!

Remember to get a convert to the Yes vote for 2013 and put an end to this nonsense. We are a great nation - be proud of it.
# murren59 2012-12-18 20:44
Yes, thank you newsnetScotland for another great year of reporting.

Staff, have a great Holiday Season and expect a wee donation from the murren'man early in the New Year.
# bipod 2012-12-19 02:51
The telegraph is having a field day with this. Apparently all of the dreaded "cyber nats" are guilty of vile anti-English rhetoric, to even question this would be further proof of this.

I don't I have ever seen a anti-English comment on here or any of the other independence supporting blogs. Whereas if you go to the dailY mail, telegraph or even the bbc comments section in their articles, you will find dozens of anti-Scottish remarks within a few minutes. It is made even more amazing when the same people making the remarks actually accuse Scottish nationalists of being racists.
# taimoshan 2012-12-19 10:07
From the Scotsman (I know, I know - but I don't buy it anymore) 8th May 2012.
Dr Mark Shephard of Strathclyde University.
to the House of Commons "discourse on Scottish Independence - Politicians versus Publics"
"The findings based on analysis of online comments under articles on independence, show that the vast majority of posts are anti-SNP/independence and anti-Salmond rather than anti-English/anti-union. In terms of language too comments about the SNP and independence are much more vitriolic than about the union and UK" Spread far and wide!
# denmylne 2012-12-20 09:18
lang may yer lum reek folks
# dadsarmy 2012-12-22 03:13
Thanks for this article. I quoted your MacAskill quote in the Guardian, and then thought I'd better check this out myself. I found table 2b - and guess what, it's correct.

Sorry for doubting you, but I'm afraid I doubt all media these days. I made an extract of the data and it's included in my posting:

Anyone is welcome to copy the fragment of data.

You must be logged-in in order to post a comment.


Donate to Newsnet Scotland


Latest Comments